Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Justin Herbert continues to spark debate—this time over his five-year, $262.5 million contract extension signed in 2023. While some see it as standard fare in today’s inflated quarterback market, others, like NFL Spin Zone’s Lou Scataglia, have labeled it the worst contract on the Chargers’ roster.
“Justin Herbert is paid like an elite QB, but besides the shiny regular season stats, what does he bring?” Scataglia wrote. “The Chargers have gotten blown out in both appearances in the postseason during the Herbert era… it just seems like there is a clear and distinct ceiling.”
Justin Herbert’s Contract Criticized—But the Los Angeles Chargers May Have Gotten a Bargain
Got That Big Dicker (The Kicker) Energy?
That criticism stems largely from Herbert’s 0–2 playoff record, including a blown 27-point lead against Jacksonville and a disastrous four-interception performance versus Houston. But does that tell the whole story?
Herbert defenders point to his undeniable talent and poor supporting cast. In 2023, he won 11 games with Quentin Johnston as his WR2 and Will Dissly—a blocking tight end—as the team’s fourth-leading receiver. He’s had four different offensive coordinators in five seasons and little help from a struggling defense.
Critics also overlook the broader quarterback market. Herbert’s deal comes in under newer extensions for Trevor Lawrence, Dak Prescott, and others—many of whom have yet to reach a Super Bowl themselves.
Herbert may not have playoff hardware—yet—but at 27, with top-tier arm talent, he still has time. Calling his deal a mistake ignores the context: the Chargers locked up a franchise quarterback in his prime, and if they finally build a real team around him, the payoff could be massive.
Subscribe to LAFB Network’s Los Angeles Chargers YouTube Channel