Last offseason’s Nolan Arenado saga felt inescapable for Los Angeles Dodgers fans. Once the St. Louis Cardinals made it clear that shedding Arenado’s contract was their top priority, the star third baseman did little to hide where he wanted to land. From carefully curated Instagram posts — including a nod to Kendrick Lamar’s “Dodger Blue” — to behind-the-scenes maneuvering, the signals were obvious.
What followed was months of contradictory reporting. MLB.com’s John Denton maintained that the Dodgers were quietly interested, while The Athletic’s Katie Woo consistently pushed back, noting there was no real traction from Los Angeles. Given Max Muncy’s firm grip on third base, many around the Dodgers believed Woo. Ultimately, that skepticism proved warranted. Arenado remained in St. Louis for 2025, despite the Cardinals’ best efforts — including a blocked deal with Houston after Arenado invoked his no-trade clause.
Support Local and Independent Sports Writing – Subscribe To the LAFB Network Today!
The Cardinals Finally Find a Path
This winter, the Cardinals took a different approach. Instead of aggressively shopping Arenado to anyone who would listen, they pulled back, recalibrated, and waited. That patience paid off.
On Tuesday, Woo reported that St. Louis was deep in talks with the Arizona Diamondbacks. Shortly thereafter, ESPN’s Jeff Passan confirmed the deal: Arenado was heading back to the National League West — just not to Chavez Ravine.
To make it happen, both sides bent. Arenado agreed to broaden the list of acceptable destinations, while the Cardinals committed to covering more than $30 million of his remaining contract. In return, St. Louis received right-handed pitching prospect Jack Martinez.
Subscribe to LAFB Network’s YouTube Channel
Why the Dodgers Passed
From the Dodgers’ perspective, this was a bullet dodged. Arenado remains an elite defender at third base, but his bat has slipped noticeably. His 2025 season in St. Louis — .237/.289/.377 with 12 home runs — was arguably the weakest of his career. While replacing Muncy with Arenado might have upgraded infield defense, the Dodgers have consistently prioritized power over glove-first improvements. Arenado simply didn’t fit that equation anymore.
Arizona’s Calculated Gamble
For the Diamondbacks, the appeal is clear. Arenado, now 34, brings an unmatched defensive résumé: eight All-Star selections, 10 Gold Gloves, and five Silver Sluggers. Arizona’s third-base defense ranked near the bottom of the league last season, and Arenado instantly stabilizes the hot corner.
Offensively, the hope lies in the environment. Chase Field has been one of the most favorable parks for right-handed hitters over the past three seasons, a stark contrast to Busch Stadium. Arenado’s pull-heavy approach could play better in the desert, even if a full resurgence is unlikely.
Given the Cardinals’ cash contribution, Arizona is essentially paying low-leverage reliever money for a short-term solution — a bridge until a younger option like Jordan Lawlar is ready.
Vote For Your Favorite Dodgers Duo: Ohtani – Yamamoto, Betts – Freeman, Hernandez – Hernandez
St. Louis Resets the Board
From St. Louis’ vantage point, this deal fits a broader retooling strategy under Chaim Bloom. By attaching significant cash, the Cardinals avoided a pure salary dump and instead secured a pitcher with some developmental upside. Martinez, just 22, has arm strength and secondary feel, even if his delivery suggests a bullpen future.
More importantly, moving Arenado clears at-bats. The Cardinals can now evaluate internal options such as Nolan Gorman, Thomas Saggese, and top prospect JJ Wetherholt as they reshape their roster for the future.
A Familiar Ending, Just a Different Uniform
In the end, Arenado got what he wanted — a return to the NL West — even if the Dodgers were never truly in play. For Los Angeles, restraint won out. For Arizona, calculated risk did. And for St. Louis, the long, exhausting saga finally closed with flexibility restored.
Sometimes, the loudest offseason storyline ends not with a splash in Los Angeles, but with a quieter landing just down the division road.